On citizen journalism
Powered by MaxBlogPress  

The day is for honest men, the night for thieves.
- Euripides

lomo-banner
Your ad here

« MRT: Seconds from disaster (UPDATED)
» New poll: Who should lead this year’s Wall of Shame?

(Un)Popular Culture, Society in General

If you can’t defend it, don’t publish it

09.10.07 | 15 Comments


If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

In his lecture for the Bloggers Kapihan, Victor Villanueva gave four tips to new bloggers. One of them is worth expounding further, and in context of what had happened in the blogosphere recently.

His four tips are as follows:

1. Know what you are saying.
2. Try to be visual.
3. Link up.
4. Go out.

For the first tip, he said the following:

* Be prepared to face the consequence(s) of what you write.
* Be prepared for confrontation.
* Deleting (or locking) entries can be futile.

Let me discuss his first tip and apply it in the context of the the Malu Fernandez controversy and the Cris Mendez case.

Bloggers took note of the mean things Malu Fernandez had said about Filipinos in general, and they blogged about it. The posts range from intellectual ones down to outright ad hominem attacks. The comments were worst. Fernandez isssued an apology and resigned from the publications who published her articles. The daily did not accept her resignation.

A show on a cable news channel took notice of what had happened, and they had invited several bloggers and journalists for a discussion. The bloggers were put on the defensive, as if the problem began with the bloggers, and the show never even bothered dealing with what Malu Fernandez wrote. Aside from an implicit validation that blogging is a new avenue for information (which for some journalists is a direct competition), it somehow made me reflect on blogging at that point.

When the time comes that a blogger has to take a stand, he has to think hard about it; when he does take a stand and blog about it, he should expect that someone will contradict him. And if the blog post is controversial enough, the blogger should expect negative comments. He should be prepared to explain, to answer questions, to receive brickbats.

Which leads me to the next issue.

Dr. Tess Termulo pointed to a blog post at a certain social networking site where the blogger said something controversial enough to merit comments that are against the blogger’s idea. The blogger cannot defend her assertions, so she locked the entry so that only a select few can read and post comments.

Remember what Bikoy had said? “Be prepared to face the consequence of what you write.” “Be prepared for confrontation.” “Deleting blog entries can be futile.”

That blogger should have attended Bloggers’ Kapihan.

You are free to write about what you feel and what you think. When you publish it for the entire world to read, expect that someone will disagree. That someone will express his disagreement. He will point out why you are wrong. There will be confrontation. If you cannot defend what you have written, if you cannot face confrontation, you are only defeating yourself. You are only showing that your stand is weak, your opinion untenable.

And locking a blog post is like deleting it - it is futile. Going back to that locked post that Dr. Termulo had pointed out, The Jester-in-Exile had managed to read the post, and published that post in his blog, together with his comments blasting the locked post to bits.

Blogging is not as simple as journal or diary writing. In writing a diary, only you can read what you write. When you blog, it can be read by everyone with an access to the Internet. I suggest that you think first, and think hard, before clicking the Publish button. If you can’t defend it, don’t blog about it. You are only putting yourself to the slaughterhouse.

UPDATE:

While this blog post is old, it is a classic example of how the blogosphere works, and ultimately, how a flawed commentary should be addressed - blasting all arguments to bits.

Like my article? Leave a tip! Or, treat me to a cup of coffee!

Visit the AWBHoldings.com Online Store!


If your comment is eaten by Akismet or just went somewhere else, please let me know. You can either leave a message at the chat box at the lower left, or via the contact page. Thanks!

RSS feed | Trackback URI

15 Comments »

Comment by Prudence
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-10 17:24:26
Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.6 on Windows Windows XP

the blogger already acknowledged her mistake.

“If you can’t defend it, don’t blog about it.”
— While that blogging is still free for everyone who has access to the Internet, people who blog just have to always bear in mind that whatever they write online is accessible by the public. Perhaps if they could password-protect it they could eliminate those they don’t want seeing their posts.

But I think it’s a better exercise to keep your blog open to public viewing because it can sharpen your skills to communicate your ideas, build rational arguments (which doesn’t necessarily mean fighting), and keep a civil conversation as much as possible. People always have this misconception that since blogging is free, “anything goes”. Of course, in a way, it is, but still, you have to remember that human beings read your blogs so treat them as human beings, just the way you’d treat them in the real world.

Also, the way you handle commenters reflects the kind of person that you are.

 
Comment by Arbet
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-10 17:27:04
Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.6 on Windows Windows XP

Hi, Dr. Tess, you put it more nicely than I could ever do.

 
Comment by joyfulchicken Subscribed to comments via email
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-10 22:06:23
Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.6 on Windows Windows XP

Malu Fernandez for president! Yay!

 
Comment by joyfulchicken Subscribed to comments via email
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-10 22:07:08
Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.6 on Windows Windows XP

Oh no! Delete delete delete!

 
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-11 00:11:26
Using WordPress WordPress 2.2.2

[...] If you can’t defend it, don’t publish it by Arbet [...]

 
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-11 03:46:33
Using WordPress WordPress 2.2.1

[...] If you can’t defend it, don’t publish it by Arbet [...]

 
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-11 11:43:38
Using WordPress WordPress MU

[...] If you can’t defend it, don’t publish it by Arbet [...]

 
Comment by cvj
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-11 12:46:52
Using Internet Explorer Internet Explorer 6.0 on Windows Windows XP

Spot on! I read somewhere that there is no such thing as the ‘right’ to an opinion. No one has a right to an opinion he/she cannot defend. (This should not be confused with the right to free speech.)

 
Comment by Arbet
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-11 17:14:46
Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.6 on Windows Windows XP

Yes, Chuck, that is true.

 
Comment by manila bay watch
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-11 22:12:48
Using Internet Explorer Internet Explorer 7.0 on Windows Windows XP

“If you can’t defend it, don’t publish it.”

Agree!

 
Comment by john marzan
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-12 13:06:13
Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.6 on Windows Windows ME

the easiest out for her of course is to apologize ASAP kung na-realize niya na mali siya.

pero kung alam mong tama ka, defend your post vigorously!

 
Comment by the jester-in-exile
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-13 16:45:53
Using Internet Explorer Internet Explorer 7.0 on Windows Windows XP

be fair… i was restraining myself. :D

 
Comment by Arbet
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-13 17:09:27
Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.6 on Windows Windows XP

Jester, I shudder to think how you would react unrestrained. :D

 
Comment by Karlo
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-14 00:11:58
Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 1.5.0.4 on Windows Windows XP

That blogger should have attended Bloggers’ Kapihan.

But that’s only in the capital, right?

On the topic at hand, it all boils down to the writer’s sense and sensibility.

 
Comment by Karlo
Comment Permalink: 2007-09-14 00:12:30
Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 1.5.0.4 on Windows Windows XP

That blogger should have attended Bloggers’ Kapihan.

But that’s only in the capital, right?

On the topic at hand, it all boils down to sense and sensibility.

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Subscribe to comments via email
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

Comments will be sent to the moderation queue.


« MRT: Seconds from disaster (UPDATED)
» New poll: Who should lead this year’s Wall of Shame?